And then there’s mobile. I switched to my phone halfway through the hunt because I was heading out. Most of those same brands became instantly unusable. Menus collapsed into weird symbols. Product photos didn’t resize properly. Fonts shrunk like they were embarrassed to be seen. Only a few held up. A24’s site, for example, somehow manages to feel cinematic even on mobile. Their structure adapts without shrinking the experience. Every scroll still feels like a decision. Every click still feels guided.
Typography told me more than I expected. A couple brands had genuinely interesting shoes but were using fonts that screamed "default." Others went the opposite direction. High-concept typefaces that looked cool but hurt to read. The Gentlewoman and Maison Kitsuné taught me how clean, confident type can set the tone before you ever say a word. Their fonts don’t overstate. They suggest. They offer. And the longer I stayed on their sites, the more I trusted that their product would have the same quiet quality.
It struck me that none of this was about trend. It was about care. Sites like Sonos, Patagonia, and Recess didn’t win me over with flash. They did it with functionality. Everything worked. Everything is loaded. Every product page told a clear story. It didn’t feel like they were chasing aesthetics. It felt like they were present. That someone, somewhere, was thinking about me as a real person with real attention, real doubt, and real curiosity.
And that’s the thing. A website doesn’t need to be an art piece. But it does need to be alive. Too many brands confuse minimalism with neglect. They think a blank page with a logo and two links makes them look mysterious. It doesn’t. It makes them look missing. Rimowa is a perfect counter-example. Their site evolves gently. Season to season. Campaign to campaign. But it never loses its core. It tells you they’re still here. They still care how you feel when you click.
I ended up buying the shoes from one of the brands with the best site. Not because it was flashy. Not because it had the most hype. But because the site made me feel like they’d thought about every step of the process. From product to purchase to presence. And that made all the difference.
So no, your website doesn’t need to go viral. But it does need to work. It needs to feel like someone’s still behind the curtain. Still adjusting the lights. Still thinking about what kind of impression you leave. Because if your site still reads like a dusty PDF—rigid, outdated, untouched—you’re not just behind. You’re invisible.